Well,no need to recap what is happening in the equity markets right now. Failure after failure of banks, investment companies, and even semi-government agencies have us running to Uncle Sam to bail us out again. But should we? These failures although damaging to many of us, are needed. These CEO’s need to be left holding the bag and be held accountable for their own misgivings. No, I do not mean jail in most instances, but really hurting those who ran these companies financially would be a good thing. Make them suffer the financial consequences and I bet you it would not happen again.
Instead, we have many companies lining up for what they believe is there “right” to a free government bailout all the while paying top CEOs millions in severance packages…
“After imposing wage cuts of up to 50 percent and other concessions on hourly workers, executives at bankrupt auto parts supplier Delphi, are seeking permission to hand themselves a multi-million dollar payout. Delphi is seeking court approval to pay 560 of its executives some $216 million in bonuses and incentives after the company comes out of bankruptcy.”
And another….both are Obama campaign consultants…
”Specifically, Dan Mudd, the CEO of Fannie Mae, is getting $9.3 million of severance for destroying his company. Richard Syron, the CEO of Freddie Mac, is getting $14.1 million--in part because of a clause he added to his employment contract two months ago, when it was clear the company was headed for disaster.” (From the Business Sheet, Blog Sept 7th)
Makes you sick doesn’t it? Well that is because they have never been forced to reap the so-called benefits of failing. They risk it all for the glory and walk away with top salaries when it fails. Both candidates stumble and feel their way around polling data to find out what to say. When what really needs to be said would be political suicide…..
”Ceo you who donate to our campaigns, take it on the chin, tough luck, you lost, now try again…..American people, when you take out a loan you cannot afford you lose….period”
Amusing, and is something that needs to be said, but NO ONE in today’s politics would say that. Ahh…I long for the days of Teddy Roosevelt, oh well.
Congress (who by the way was supposed to be watching this) has done nothing up until now except blame the other party, (who is in control is to blame has been a regular practice for some party but WAIT not when it applies to THEM!!!) What is going on? Where we all these people when the crisis was looming? Where was congress, oh yeah congress, where were all these smart people when this was a growing problem? They were watching and hoping SOMEONE else (insert, another party) could take the blame.
Yes as accusations fly from both sides of the aisles, we the people hold the bag and hold our breath. Really we should be holding our nose. Our markets, whether unregulated or over regulated were broken a long time ago.
Our market valuation system never accounted for adjustments but rewarded greed and over leveraging. Why not leverage? By leveraging you can make more money without using much of your own. This is a great investment theory and it works too, but NOT without limitations. You cannot leverage $50 for every $1 you invest without putting yourself at such risk you lose $100. In real estate clients would buy a piece of land start to build a home on it, take a loan out (because they would have 70% equity) then use that equity loan to start the next process of buying land starting to build and leveraging that project to start the next one. That is all well and good if you can sell the first to pay off the second and then sell the second to reap all the rewards. But that is just it, our wall street markets were not waiting to start the next project when the sold the previous leveraged asset and paid it off. They just kept on leveraging hoping that sooner or later it would all work itself out. And in Wall Street’s situation it will, by a trillion dollar payout to rescue them from overleveraging themselves when they knew what they were doing was risky.
What is the POINT of calling it risky of you eliminate failure? Bottom line, our markets need to fail, once and a while. We need these over leveraged companies and fat cat ceos to be held accountable and be open to monetary failure. The problem comes in when by doing this we harm a lot of people who DIDN’T do these things….who may you ask….the middle class. How can we let these people fail and yet still protect the average investor? That will be the great debate.
I think regulation is required, but this regulation MUST adapt to the ever changing and over complicated markets. Don’t allow these companies to leverage to such an extent, clearer books, and if a company goes into bankruptcy, disallow any ceo payouts from a year to the day filing for bankruptcy. Financial insolvency must start from the top down.
I am for capitalism with common sense and responsibility BUT also with the RISK of failure. After all with failure comes the realization of mistakes. Mistakes lead to fixing the mistakes or not repeating them. Think about it, isn’t failure the single most important element to success? With failure you learn and never do that again, and next time around you have the memory of that mistake to correct you in the future. Or is it the FEAR of failure that drives some people to never accept less than success.
I think this starts as children, our schools have created such an atmosphere of “don’t worry no one fails here”. “Trying something is as good as not trying something and way better than failing someone.” This creates thee atmosphere that someone will always be along to rescue them and make things right. NO, that does not always work.
I believe the government serves a purpose, that purpose is limited and should be used in extreme cases. Here in this market we do have an extreme case, but only because we allowed these investors to think that there was no possibility of failure, the government would always step in and save them, thus….NO REAL RISK. No, in life we need ups and downs, we need failures and we need success. Although, believe me that easier said than done in your own life isn’t it?
Basic economics tell us that with high prices come low demand and with low demand comes lower prices, this is the cycle we need. With investment comes risk with risk comes profit, not bailouts. So we need it, but what we DON'T need is the extreme swing this has brought on, we need educated buyers, who understand what they are doing. We need CEOs who are held financially liable for their mistakes, investors who not only understand their risk but prepare for it. And if they don't, they take the financial hit and the responsibility.
What makes our country great is at the end of the day we all will be able to breathe again and one day remember this day and smile that we NEVER made that mistake again. We failed but yet we move on, making things better and learning from feeling our mistakes first hand. So please businesses, learn to embrace failure, live with the fear of failing, it just might bring about the next best business model.
Hey just for fun check out the Socialists idea of a solution…I KNOW you see the faults in this one……hahaha have fun and breathe a sigh of relief that these extremist will never have more power than ordering a coffee from a local coffee shop. Ryan S. Carrigan
*********************************************
“From the American Socialist Movement website------ American capitalism has become the global leader in the creation of personal wealth for the ruling elite entirely separated from the creation of real value in the process of production. The current economic breakdown, which threatens the world’s people with catastrophe, is the inevitable result. The alternative to the naked dictatorship of capital and the impoverishment of the working people is socialism. The Socialist Equality Party insists that if the resources of the American people must be mobilized to avert an economic catastrophe, then the American working people should assume control of the financial institutions and use them for the common good, not corporate profit and personal enrichment. We propose that the major banks and financial institutions be nationalized and turned into public utilities, operated under the democratic control of the working population. The vast financial resources that they control must be used to provide decent education, housing, health care, retirement benefits and good-paying jobs for all. This should be carried out without compensation to their former owners, while securing the deposits and savings of working people and small business owners. The billions of dollars in social wealth diverted into the private accounts of speculators and bankers must be recovered, to be used for the expansion of social programs that benefit the masses. There must be a public accounting of the fraud and corruption that have fueled the crisis, and those responsible must be held accountable, including by means of criminal prosecution. The books of the major banks, financial firms, insurance companies and hedge funds must be opened to public examination, to lay bare illegal and socially destructive activity. The Socialist Equality Party and its candidates for president and vice president, Jerome White and Bill Van Auken, advocate the creation of a workers’ government—a government of, by and for the working class—to carry out emergency measures to resolve the crisis in the interests of working people, including a halt to all foreclosures and repossession of homes, the creation of millions of public works jobs, a ban on wage-cutting and layoffs, and an enormous expansion in public services. We issue an urgent appeal to all those who oppose the bankrupting of society for the benefit of the financial elite, who wish to defend the interests of working people, and who see the need for a socialist alternative to the two parties of big business: Support the SEP election campaign and its candidates, Jerome White and Bill Van Auken. Join the Socialist Equality Party.
*****************************************
WOW, now that is a misguided perception of reality….Good luck in 2008 guys.
Recent Comments